The Chair Was Already Empty

Kenneth “Ken” Arnold who has been running the Board of Veterans’ Appeals told everyone at the Board this week that he is retiring quitting. He leaves behind 141,729 pending appeals, a workforce that told its own union it has no confidence in leadership, the poorest quality of decisions we have ever seen, and a vacuum of leadership.

Official portrait of Kenneth A. Arnold, Acting Chairman of the Board of Veterans’ Appeals
Kenneth A. Arnold, who has run the Board of Veterans’ Appeals as its acting head since January 2025, told employees at a town hall this week that he is retiring. Official Department of Veterans Affairs photograph.

Man, I love my new birdie who keeps sending over this union stuff. Another one of their newsletters landed in my inbox. AFGE Local 17, which represents some of the attorneys and staff at the Board, told its members that at a town hall the day before, Acting Chairman Ken Arnold announced his “retirement”.

I will say the quiet part first. My gut reaction was two words long and the second one was “finally.” But, one man leaving a job is not a reform. What matters is the pile he hands to the next person, and whether anybody makes her fix it.

So let us talk about the pile.

Twenty-One Months of "Acting"

Here is a thing most Veterans do not know, and most Veterans would be pissed to learn.

The Chairman of the Board is supposed to be nominated by the President and confirmed by the Senate for a six-year term. That is in the statute, at 38 U.S.C. § 7101(b)(1). Congress wrote it that way on purpose. The person who sets the rules for how your appeal gets decided is supposed to be somebody who had to sit in front of a Senate committee and answer for it.

The Board has not had one of those since January 15, 2025.

That is the day Jaime Areizaga-Soto quit, too. I use that word on purpose. The Board is there to serve Veterans. They shouldn’t be resigning because of who is in office, D or R. Although, he says he had to leave due to military obligations, or something like that. Back to the story. He had been confirmed in August 2022, sworn in that September, and his term ran to 2028. He left early, citing a 2 active-duty mobilization. Ken Arnold, the Vice Chairman, stepped in to run the juke joint.

And then nothing happened for a long time.

A nominee named Terrance Gorman went up in August 2025. The nomination was withdrawn about a month later. The seat sat empty. Maria Chapa Lopez was nominated on June 1, 2026 — a former U.S. Attorney for the Middle District of Florida and a retired Army lieutenant colonel. Her nomination hearing was September 23, 2026, in front of Chairman Moran’s committee, the same hearing I wrote about here two weeks ago.

As of today, she has not been confirmed.

Witness list from the September 23, 2026 Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee nomination hearing
The witness list from the Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee’s September 23, 2026, nomination hearing. “For a term of six years” is what the statute promises. The Board has been run by an acting official since January 2025.

So, count it up, Buster. 21 months with an acting official at the top of the agency that decides whether a Veteran’s appeal lives or dies. 21 months of a man who could be replaced at any moment making decisions about quotas, staffing, and how 141,729 appeals get sequenced. Nobody in that chair had to answer to the Senate for any of it, because nobody in that chair was confirmed by the Senate.

I am not saying that isn’t copacetic with the law. The statute lets a Vice Chairman carry the load, and somebody has to. I am saying it is no way to run an appellate body, and it is a terrible way to run a backlog.

About his Legacy

Local 17’s letter is blunt about the culture under Arnold, and I am going to let the union speak for itself, because these are its members and its survey.

AFGE LOCAL 17, OCTOBER 2026The workplace culture at the Board of Veterans’ Appeals has become legendary — and not for reasons anyone would want on a résumé. Attorneys are anxious about production quotas and PIPs, administrative professionals are overwhelmed by staffing shortages, and experienced employees are leaving, sometimes at considerable financial sacrifice.

The union’s survey numbers are the backbone of it. This week’s letter puts a new one on the table: 81% of the Board’s attorneys expressed no confidence in Board leadership. The ones I reported here two weeks ago are no gentler. 97% said the increased production standards have made factual or legal errors more likely. 93% said the standards do not leave enough time for meaningful review. 64% said they have cut back on reviewing the evidence just to keep pace. The quota itself is 182 decisions a year per attorney, which is a finished Board decision about every day and a half, every working day, forever. Keep in mind, some Board decisions can have a list of issues a mile long. Service-connection for 4 things, higher rating for this, earlier effective date for that.

This is not new information to anybody at the Board. In June 2024, Local 17 pointed out that the Board had ranked 444th out of 459 agency subcomponents in the federal employee survey, dropping more than ten points in a year, and put the blame directly on the Chairman and Vice Chairman by name. Arnold was the Vice Chairman then. He has been at the Board since February 2019 and Vice Chairman since January 2020. Whatever the culture is, it didn’t arrive last night.

How about this? In defense of ‘ole Ken, how can you be blamed when you aren’t doing any work? Word from a few inside Board attorneys is that he sits in his office all day rubber necking anyhow.

And underneath the percentages and quotas are people. The letter tells two stories that stand out to me.

The first is an attorney who resigned after nearly ten years, taking substantially less pay to go somewhere else. Years of unpaid overtime. Declining health. Feeling guilty for stepping away from her computer long enough to make her child dinner. Faced with a “performance improvement plan,” she refused to cut the quality of her legal work or spend her nights chasing a number. Her exit interview produced one sentence that ought to be read into the record of every oversight hearing from here to Christmas:

AN ATTORNEY WHO LEFT THE BOARD, QUOTED BY AFGE LOCAL 17It didn’t feel like I mattered at the Board.

The second is an attorney retiring early after more than 25 years, taking reduced retirement benefits to get out. She pushed her retirement date back by four weeks. Her new Veterans Law Judge (her supervisor), a judge the union says has never drafted a Board decision himself, responded with a productivity lecture and a warning about a possible PIP, four workdays into the fiscal year.

25 years. 4 days. She wrote back:

A RETIRING BOARD ATTORNEY, QUOTED BY AFGE LOCAL 17After more than 25 years as a decision-writing attorney, I am well aware of my professional obligations and do not need to be reminded to "finish strong."

Yikes. Good for her, and I will say it louder than the union did.

Here is why a Veteran should care about any of this, and it is not sentiment. Those are the people who read your file. When nearly two-thirds of the attorneys deciding these appeals tell their own union they have cut back on reviewing the evidence to keep pace, that is not a human resources problem. That is your nexus opinion getting missed. That is your lay statement getting one sentence of boilerplate. That is a remand you did not need and three more years you don’t get back.

There’s a saying. Nothing worse than a hungry judge stuck in a hearing at 11:45 in the morning. But, get that same judge after a nice lunch (maybe a good cigar), and you can butter him up for everything. Well, right now, every Board attorney is hungry, grumpy—and rightfully so.

Now About That Inventory

I know. You are sick to death of me yapping about data. A workplace culture story is easy for VA to keep under wraps. Numbers are harder. So here is what is actually sitting at the Board, from the Board’s own records, which I obtained under FOIA and published here last month.

As of July 9, 2026:

  • 141,729 appeals pending. That is not the VBA claims backlog. That is just the Board’s pending inventory.
  • 98.3% of them have been passed over, meaning an appeal filed later, on the same docket, has already been decided while yours sits.
  • 3,497 have been pending five years or more. The oldest was filed in June 2018.
  • 41,589 have been pending three years or more.
  • The median pending appeal has been waiting 609 days. On the hearing docket, where 82,509 of them sit, the median is 800 days.
  • In the twelve months ending July 9, 2026, the Board dispatched 86,757 decisions. For those, the median wait from filing to decision was 518 days.
Bar chart of 141,729 appeals pending at the Board of Veterans’ Appeals by how long each has been waiting
The Board’s own active-appeals file, released to The Spectator under FOIA 26-19815-F. Chart by The Veteran’s Spectator.

Read the second bullet again, because it is the one that matters. Congress wrote 38 U.S.C. § 7107 to say appeals get decided in docket order, first in, first out. Just like the DMV. The Board’s own spreadsheet says that is happening for about one appeal in sixty.

That is what Maria Chapa Lopez inherits, assuming the Senate ever gets around to confirming her. Not a tidy in-box. A line that is 141,729 people long, in which almost everybody has been cut in front of, and a workforce that has told its union it does not trust the people running it.

The Ones Who Have Been Waiting Longest

The spreadsheet does not tell me who those 3,497 five-year cases belong to. It gives me a docket number and a date, and that is all.

But I know who sits in my waiting room. A fair number of them are Vietnam Veterans, still working on something, the heart condition, the diabetes, the PTSD, the thing nobody would call service-connected in 1974. Or, the Gulf War Veteran with strange neurological problems. (Wonder why?)

Vietnam Veterans marching behind a banner reading We Won’t Fight Another Rich Man’s War
Vietnam Veterans Against the War on the march. The banner says what a good many of them had worked out by then.

Here is what the Vietnam generation understood that we keep having to learn over again. VA has never once fixed itself quietly.

Agent Orange did not become a presumptive because somebody at Central Office read the science and did the right thing. It took a lawsuit, a class action (Nehmer), and an act of Congress. Camp Lejeune took thirty years and a dying man’s testimony. Burn pits took twenty years, a comedian on a Senate stairwell, and the PACT Act. Every single line on the presumptive list is there because somebody would not shut up about it.

And the men who taught that lesson first were the ones who came to Washington in their own field jackets and said it out loud.

Members of Vietnam Veterans Against the War with raised fists behind a hand-lettered banner at the Statue of Liberty
Vietnam Veterans Against the War at the Statue of Liberty. Field jackets, a bedsheet, a marker, and no press office.

In April 1971 better than two thousand of them came to the Capitol for six days they called Dewey Canyon III, a limited incursion, they said, into the country of Congress. On the last morning they walked up to a fence the government had put between them and the Capitol steps and threw their medals over it. 14 Navy and Distinguished Service Crosses. 100 Silver Stars. More than 1,000 Purple Hearts.

A Veteran throwing a medal toward the Capitol steps during Operation Dewey Canyon III in April 1971
Dewey Canyon III, April 23, 1971. Over about three hours, Veterans threw medals, ribbons and discharge papers over a fence the government had put up in front of the Capitol steps.

Nobody at VA enjoyed that week. The presumptives came anyway.

I bring it up because there is a version of this story where the retirement of one acting official counts as progress, and everybody goes back to waiting politely. That is not how any of this has ever worked. The Board attorneys filling out their union’s survey are making noise from the inside. The FOIA requests are making noise from the outside. Both are necessary and neither is rude.

And One More Thing on Her Desk

There is a piece of this that is in front of the Court right now on this issue.

In Cartwright v. Collins, Vet. App. No. 26-0888, we have a petition pending at the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims, along with a request to certify a class of Veterans whose appeals the Board has decided out of docket order. The FOIA data above is in the Court’s records. The Secretary says the case is moot since Mr. Cartwright got his appeal decided after filing a petition (imagine that). We say no wait a minute, the “harm is capable of repetition and evading review,” which is a fancy way of saying they can keep doing this to one Veteran at a time forever if nobody makes them stop.

Whoever is sitting in the Chairman’s office when that gets decided will have to live with the answer. Arnold’s retirement does not change the question, and it does not change the data. A new nameplate on the door does not move anybody up in line.

What Would Actually Count as Different

I have no interest in a honeymoon. Damn things are expensive. Those of you with a few marriages know what I am talking about! If the new Chairman wants to be judged on something other than her predecessor’s record, there is a short list, and none of it requires an act of Congress.

  • Publish the docket data. Quarterly. Period. Pending appeals by docket type and receipt date, decisions by receipt date. Let anybody check the order for themselves. If the Board is following § 7107, this costs nothing and proves it. If it is not, we already know.
  • Say out loud what the quota is and what it is based on. If 182 is the right number, show the work. If 97% of your attorneys say it is producing errors, that is evidence, not whining.
  • Fix the hearing docket or admit it is broken. 82 thousand Veterans are waiting a median of 800 days on the docket they chose because they wanted to talk to a judge. That is the Board’s single biggest failure and it barely gets mentioned.
  • Earn it. Local 17 put this better than I can: the next Chairman "will inherit a workforce whose trust must be earned, not demanded." Same goes for ours.

One Last Thing

I want to be fair to Ken Arnold on one point, because The Spectator is not in the business of pretending.

He did not build this alone. He stepped into an acting role he did not ask to hold for 20ish months, under a Secretary whose anti-worker posture Local 17 has been documenting since January, in a department that has been shedding experienced people faster than it can replace them. The problems at the Board are older than his tenure and bigger than his office. The union says so itself, and the union is not inclined to do him any favors.

But a leader owns the weather. The quotas went up on his watch. The survey numbers came in on his watch. The attorneys who left, left on his watch, and the ones still there told a pollster what they think of the people in charge. You do not get to run a place for 21 months and then hand off the consequences with the keys. And, if someone above you was making demands you knew hurt Veterans, it was your duty to throw your rank on the table and say “Can’t do it. This hurts Veterans and I will not stand for it. If you need to fire me, I understand, but I cannot do what you are asking.” Used to, that is what men of leadership did. Used to.

So: good luck to him, and goodbye, and don’t let the door hit ya on the way out.

To the Veterans reading this who have an appeal sitting in that pile, I know a change at the top does not feel like anything from where you are standing. It is not supposed to, yet. Watch what the next one does in the first ninety days. That is when you find out.

And to the folks still working at the Board, the ones reading their own union’s letter and recognizing themselves in it, a lot of us out here know exactly who is doing the actual work on these appeals, and it is not the person whose name is on the door.

Keep your heads up.

Godspeed.

Wesley McCauley

While working as the Operations Lieutenant for his local fire department during college, Wesley found his love for veteran’s law. Wesley was born and raised in rural south Georgia, where he continues to enjoy living. While attending Valdosta State University, a community also home to Moody Air Force Base, Wesley saw the lack of quality representation available to Veterans and their families—even in a military community. This led him to become a VA accredited representative, seeking to serve Veterans and their families. Following his time in the Fire Department, he founded United Veteran’s Disability in September of 2021.

Wesley has represented some of our nation’s finest, including a World War II POW, combat Veterans, Camp Lejeune Veterans, submariners, Vietnam widows, Coastguardsmen, Infantrymen, FBI agents, and even VA employees. Wesley says each have a common thread “love of country.” He has successfully recovered millions in benefits for veterans and their families. His largest single recovery totals over $525,000 in backpay. Wesley has represented Veterans and their families at the Regional Office level, the Board of Veterans’ Appeals, and the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims. He has handled both medically and legally complex claims. Wesley believes in the importance of maximizing benefits for veterans, and his clients are regularly awarded SMC to help compensate veterans above the 100% rate.

While Wesley represents a wide range of Veterans and survivors, a large part of his practice includes veterans exposed to toxic burn pits. “What we saw with Vietnam veterans and Agent Orange is playing itself over again, but with burn pit Veterans. As we continue to learn more about the diseases associated with burn pit exposure, it is important to hold the VA accountable and push for many more diseases to be presumptive, just as the Vietnam Veterans had to fight decades for.”

Wesley is a sustaining member of the National Organization for Veterans’ Advocates, a member of the CAVC Bar Association, Military-Veterans Advocacy, and is a lifetime member of the National Eagle Scout Association.

Outside of his practice, Wesley enjoys traveling with his wife, especially visiting our U.S. National Parks. Together, they plan to visit all 63 U.S. National Parks. They also enjoy exercising together, as well as nature photography.

https://unitedforvets.us
Previous
Previous

Duty to Maximize Avoidance: Mr. Hoffman and VA’s Intent to File Letter

Next
Next

Nobody Gets Left Behind.