On the issues

Where we stand

A publication that tells you it has no side is either lying to you or is not paying attention. Here is where we stand, issue by issue, and underneath each position, what we have to say about it with plain talk. Positions are cheap. The record is the part that costs something.

01

Contract examiners who cannot see the file

An opinion written by somebody who was never handed the claims file is not a medical opinion. It is a guess on letterhead.

VA buys examinations by the thousand from contract vendors. The examiner is asked whether a condition is related to service — a question nobody can answer without reading what is in the file — and is then not given the file. VA relies on the answer anyway, and the Veteran gets the denial.

The record Documented since 2023. A FOIA request to VBA asks how contract examiners actually access a Veteran's file. The exhibits include a September 2023 departmental email stating in plain terms that the examiner is not granted access to the entire claims file, a quality review that faulted the request rather than the access, examination reports citing “file access issues,” and a vendor job posting for a “Medical Record Bookmarker.” Raised with the Under Secretary for Benefits, and raised on the front end of the cases I handle.

02

Whether the Board decides appeals in the order it got them

38 U.S.C. § 7107 is not a suggestion. A Veteran who has waited years should not watch appeals docketed after his go out the door ahead of him.

Docket order is the one promise the Board makes that a Veteran can actually check, if somebody makes the Board produce the numbers.

The record A FOIA request produced the Board's own spreadsheets of active and dispatched appeals. Those figures are in the record at the Court in Cartwright v. Collins, No. 26-0888, a mandamus petition with a pending request for class certification. A follow-up request covering Legacy hearing appeals is outstanding; the fee was paid under protest and the fee determination is on appeal.

03

Rules written in a manual instead of a regulation

M21-1 is guidance. Adjudicators apply it like law, and Veterans lose claims on provisions that never went through notice and comment.

If a rule is binding enough to decide a claim, it is binding enough to be published, opened for comment, and reviewed by a court. If it is not, it should not be deciding anything.

The record A petition under 38 C.F.R. § 5.20, filed August 11, 2026, asking VA to withdraw the M21-1 note instructing adjudicators that lay testimony alone cannot establish tinnitus. And McCauley v. Secretary of Veterans Affairs, No. 26-2152, a petition for review in the Federal Circuit under 38 U.S.C. § 502.

04

Examination quality and examiner accountability

“I said no, and I am a specialist” is not a rationale. An opinion with no reasoning in it cannot be weighed, and a decision leaning on one is not supported by the evidence.

The same handful of examiners turn up in claims file after claims file, writing the same unsupported conclusions, and VA keeps sending them Veterans.

The record FOIA requests seeking the body of work of particular compensation and pension examiners whose opinions keep appearing in files and whose reasoning does not survive contact with the record.

05

Caregivers

Families restructure their entire lives around a caregiver award. Taking it away on a clinical judgment nobody writes down is not a decision a Veteran can appeal in any meaningful sense.

PCAFC decisions turn on assessments that are rarely explained in a way anyone can test, and the paths out of a bad one are confusing by design.

The record Caregiver denials and downgrades taken to the Board, rather than left in the clinical appeal channels where they go to die.

06

Outfits charging Veterans for claims help

Taking a cut of a Veteran's retroactive award to prepare a claim, without accreditation, is against the law. That it has become common does not make it less so.

A Veteran who did not know the help was free should not end up owing five figures out of the first check.

The record Covered as it comes up, with names, under Claims Sharks.

These positions move when the evidence does

Every one of these is held because of something in a record, and every one of them is open to being wrong. If you have a document that shows otherwise, send it. Not only will we run a correction, we’ll offer you the opportunity to give your side.

★★★