All rise. The Court of Public Opinion is now in session, the People of the United States presiding. The Court will now hear the case of Denis McDonough, Secretary of Pullin’ Your Leg, versus Douglas A. Collins, Secretary of Speed.
The midterms were a report card. Voters looked at the people holding the job and decided whether they should keep holding it. Agree or disagree, it was a rebuke of what voters were promised versus what they got. VA has had two Secretaries in 6 years and you didn’t get to vote on either one. So here is their report card, graded against VA’s own spreadsheets, two federal courts, a memo VA never announced, and 10 days in February that nobody at the Department wants to talk about.
A fresh coat of paint
Check out the new website. The Veteran’s Spectator has its own domain now, its own company, and its own front door at theveteransspectator.com. The old address at unitedforvets.us/spectator sends you here. Nothing you were reading has gone anywhere, and every post that ran before this one came along with the move.
Here is why it moved. We file Freedom of Information Act requests, and VA answers them, and what comes back answers questions Veterans have been asking for years. For a long time those records went into a file drawer. A drawer is a terrible place for a public record. So, the records now live in Declassified, a searchable archive on this site, and when a story here quotes a document you can open the document and read the page the quote came from. That is the whole idea. You should not have to take our word for anything.
It also makes continuing our FOIA requests much easier. The VA previously kept wanting us to pay up saying we aren’t real news media. Well, hopefully this new set up solves all that. Still though, doing business with the devil costs. We still have to file lawsuits, and those cost money. But I love messin’ with them so much it is worth it.
Anyhow, enough house keepin’.
Grading the help
On November 3 the country filled out a report card. That is really all a midterm is. Nobody gets to vote on the Secretary of Veterans Affairs, which is a shame, because the office has more effect on the daily life of a Veteran than most of the names that were actually on the ballot.
So let us do the grading ourselves, on the two men who have held it in recent years. Denis R. McDonough, sworn in February 9, 2021, out the door January 20, 2025; and Douglas A. Collins, confirmed 77 to 23 on February 4, 2025, and sworn in the next day by Justice Thomas. Four years for the first man. Just shy of 2 years and counting for the second guy. Both jokers.
And let’s grade them on something they can’t write a press release about.
Monday morning report
Every Monday morning VA publishes a spreadsheet. It is called the Monday Morning Workload Report, it is deeply boring, and it is the closest thing the Veterans Benefits Administration has to a pulse. It says how many claims are sitting there, how many have been sitting there longer than 125 days, and how long the average one has been waiting.
We downloaded every edition from February 2021 through November 14, 2026. 303 of them. One from January 2023 would not open. Wonder why? The other 302 did. The chart at the top of this page is built from them, the spreadsheet behind it is at the bottom of this page, and you are welcome to check our numbers.
Two numbers matter. Inventory is every claim pending a decision. Backlog is the part of that pile older than 125 days. VA’s own definitions, not ours:
Here is what the two men were handed and what they handed on.
McDonough took office with 478,032 claims pending and 212,851 of them past 125 days, or 44.5 percent of the pile, which is to say nearly half of everyone waiting was already waiting too long. The week before he left? 956,215 pending, 252,406 past 125 days, or 26.4 percent.
Check that again, because both halves are true. The share of Veterans stuck in the backlog fell by eighteen points under McDonough. And the total number of claims sitting at VA exactly doubled — up 100.0 percent, from 478,032 to 956,215. The average claim’s wait fell from 151.6 days to 104.5.
The honest explanation for the doubling is not incompetence, and anyone who tells you it is has not looked. The PACT Act was signed in August 2022 and did what it was designed to do: it opened the door to a very large number of people who had been shut out. Inventory peaked at 1,098,487 on October 7, 2023. The backlog peaked at 417,855 on January 6, 2024. McDonough spent his last year digging out of a hole that Congress, correctly, dug for him.
On a side tangent, I have said ‘till I am blue in the face, anyone saying the numbers of claims we have is unexpected is an idiot. You could have seen this stuff coming from miles away. But no one in government was watching. What am I talking about? Well, we have the Vietnam generation all 70+ as of this writing, assuming Johnnie turned 17 during the fall of Saigon. Those Veterans are, rightfully so, turning to the VA for their end-of-life care. Then we have two Gulf Wars, 9/11, and everything in-between. Oh, then the PACT Act, the largest piece of liberalizing legislation for VA benefits in history. And that doesn’t even consider the few 200,000+ Korean War Veterans still kicking, and even a few WW II ones out there.
So, anyone who says they didn’t see the volume of claims incoming is not someone who should be in leadership at the VA.
Alright, tangent over.
Meanwhile, Collins took office with 953,078 pending and 254,679 past 125 days, at 26.7 percent, which is basically the same hand McDonough put down three weeks earlier. As of November 14, 2026, 725,257 pending and 84,811 past 125 days, at 11.7 percent. The backlog is down 66.7 percent. Inventory is down 23.9 percent. Average days pending went from 102.3 to 66.8.
Two thirds of the backlog is gone. If the only question on the report card were how fast, Collins wins it, and it is not even close.
The sound of silence
Except the trend turned, and as far as we can tell nobody has talked about it.
The backlog bottomed out at 68,207 on June 27, 2026. That was the best week VA has had since before the pandemic. Remember the Freedom 250 Challenge I wrote about? Since then, it has gone up almost every week, and on November 14 it stood at 84,811, up 16,604 claims, or 24.3 percent, in 20 weeks.
The inventory turned earlier and harder. It bottomed at 563,229 on April 25, 2026, and has since climbed to 725,257. That is 162,028 more claims, a 28.8 percent increase, in under 7 months. Average days pending bottomed at 61.9 in September and is back to 66.8.
VA’s April 2026 press release said the backlog had fallen below 100,000 for the first time since 2020, which was true when they wrote it. In August the Secretary told a radio show the average wait was down to about 78 days and that he wanted it between 30 and 45. He also said something more revealing, about how the gains had been produced:
That is a confession dressed as an accomplishment. VA’s own April release credited the improvement to “focused leadership, hard work and targeted use of overtime.” Overtime is not a reform. It is a withdrawal against people, and the account was being drawn down while the FY2026 budget request cut the Veterans Benefits Administration from 33,443 full-time employees to 31,401. 2,042 fewer, a 6 percent cut, and cut the Board of Veterans’ Appeals from 1,405 to 1,320.
Fewer people, more overtime, and a curve that bottomed in June and has gone the wrong way every month since. You do not need a theory about why. You just need the spreadsheet.
But now, by the way, we need to hire 2,000 new employee to process claims? Talk about a walking disaster. Fire everyone. Issue shoddy decisions, then bring back 2,000 people when the appeals are back up. I must admit, he is a good politician.
Speed was never the grade
Here is the thing about a claims backlog. You can always make it smaller. Deny everything on Tuesday and the backlog is zero on Wednesday. Speed is only a virtue if the decisions are right, which means the real report card is not how fast did you move the pile but what did you do to the Veteran at the bottom of it.
On that question both men have a case against them, and they are worth laying side by side, because they are the same case.
Secretary of pullin’ your leg
Daniel D. Barry lost his right leg above the knee. He is service connected for that and for a long list of other things. Post-traumatic stress disorder at 70 percent, a right shoulder at 60, and more below that. He received special monthly compensation under 38 U.S.C. § 1114(m) with one intermediate-rate increase under 38 C.F.R. § 3.350(f)(3), and he asked for the additional increases his other disabilities should have bought him.
VA said no. VA said § 3.350(f)(3) gives you one increase and only one. The Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims agreed with VA in a split decision, over a dissent that said the regulation’s plain text allowed more than one.
On May 16, 2024, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit told Denis McDonough’s VA it had been reading its own regulation wrong all along:
Unambiguously. Not a close call, not a question on which reasonable people differ. The regulation was never ambiguous, and VA had spent years reading it the way that paid amputees less, men like Mr. Barry. The court reversed, remanded for VA to work out how many increases Mr. Barry should actually have received.
Ten days in February
Ten Days in February. Kinda sounds like the name of a history book or something spooky. Carlton H. Ingram is an Army Veteran with a bad back and a bad left ankle. He takes opioids for the pain. He consented to long-term opioid therapy in April 2015, which is in the record. He argued the Board had to consider how disabled he is without the medication, because the diagnostic codes for his back and ankle, 5237 and 5271, say nothing about medication at all.
On March 12, 2025, five weeks into Secretary Collins’s tenure, a three-judge panel of the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims agreed with him, extending Jones v. Shinseki to musculoskeletal ratings:
The court also said “nope” of the Secretary’s argument that pain medication solves the problem, in nine words that should be printed on the wall of every regional office. To “alleviate” pain does not mean to eliminate it.
Now, Collins had only been on the job a few weeks. But what transpired is all on his watch. First, VA appealed to the Federal Circuit. Then tried to legislate around the loss. On February 17, 2026, VA published an interim final rule rewriting 38 C.F.R. § 4.10 with no advance notice, no comment period before it took effect, effective the day it printed. The new text said this:
Authorized by DC himself. So, if the pill works, you get paid less for the condition the pill is treating. Stop taking it and your rating goes back up. That is the choice the rule put in front of every Veteran on a pain regimen, and VA put it there on purpose, in writing, to undo a court decision it had lost eleven months earlier.
VA was candid about the motive. Its own preamble said Ingram could reach more than 500 diagnostic codes and force re-adjudication of more than 350,000 pending claims, and it justified skipping notice and comment on the ground that waiting would be:
Among the harms VA listed was “higher compensation expenditures based on disability levels veterans are not experiencing.” The harm, in other words, was paying Veterans what the court had just said they were owed. Again, Secretary Collins approved that rule personally.
Then all hell broke loose. Roughly 20,000 people filed comments. More than 20 members of Congress wrote to the Secretary. On February 19 Collins said VA would not enforce the rule while insisting it remained in effect. On the 22nd his Deputy Secretary told the DAV Mid-Winter Conference it had been withdrawn, which was news to the Federal Register, where nothing had been withdrawn at all.
Of course, I did not watch that from the stands. By February 25, when Stars and Stripes reported it, I was one of four petitioners along with the MilVet Law Firm, Derek Debus, and a Vietnam Veteran named Andrew Laffoon, a client of mine, in a petition for review under 38 U.S.C. § 502 asking the Federal Circuit to throw the rule out in the trash can of history. What I told that paper was that VA “can turn enforcement on just as easily as they supposedly turned it off.” A promise not to enforce a rule is not the same thing as not having the rule.
Two days later it was gone. VA rescinded the rule and put the old § 4.10 back, ten days after printing it. Collins approved the rescission on February 24, 13 days after he approved the rule itself. The rescission notice is one page, and the most important sentence in it is the one that gives away why it happened:
VA’s own appeal in Ingram was dismissed on March 30 after enough public outcry. Nobody won anything in court. The rule simply stopped existing, because 20,000 people noticed it in 10 days.
One question the rescission notice does not answer, whether the rule was applied to anybody’s claim during the ten days it was on the books. VA published it as effective immediately, told the public two days later that it would not be enforced, and then removed it without ever saying what happened to the claims decided in between.
Biological truth
In June 2024 VA put male breast cancer on the PACT Act’s presumptive list. It did it by reading the statutory category “reproductive cancer of any type” in 38 U.S.C. § 1120 to cover breast cancer in men as well as women, after a working group of its own experts looked at the medicine.
That autumn McDonough’s VA wrote the reasoning down where anyone could argue with it. The proposed rule was approved and signed by the Secretary himself on September 19, 2024, and published on October 1:
That is what a decision looks like when it is made out of medicine. Mutational signatures. Common risk factors. The footnote hanging off that sentence is an endocrinology paper.
That bothered Doug Collins. In September 2025, Secretary Collins signed a memo taking it back off, effective September 30. A man diagnosed after that date no longer gets the presumption. He has to prove his cancer came from his service, which is the exact burden the PACT Act was written to lift. The memo was not announced. The public found out on October 29, when ProPublica obtained it.
The authority the memo leaned on was not a study. It was an executive order called “Defending Women from Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government.” VA’s spokesman stated the Department’s position without embarrassment:
Whether “reproductive cancer of any type” reaches male breast cancer is a question about what a statute means, and VA’s reading is not absurd on its face. We argue statutes for a living and we have made thinner arguments than that one.
But look at what changed between September 2024 and September 2025, and what did not. The mutational signatures did not change. The risk factors did not change. The treatment did not change. A VA oncologist told ProPublica the plain thing, that whatever you call it, “the treatment is the same.” What changed was an executive order about something else entirely.
Look also at how each decision was made. The first went into the Federal Register with footnotes and a comment period, where anybody who disagreed could say so. The second went out as an internal memo and surfaced because a reporter got hold of it.
Roughly a hundred men a year are diagnosed. That small number is the point. There was no budget emergency here and no flood of claims to manage. There was a phrase in an executive order and a benefit category that could be made to fit it.
Congress noticed. On October 22, 2026, 4 weeks ago, Representatives Rick Larsen and Maxine Dexter introduced the Veteran Breast Cancer Fairness Act, H.R. 10882, which would write the presumption for male breast cancer straight into title 38 where no memo can reach it. It is sitting in the House Veterans’ Affairs Committee. Senator Blumenthal’s Presumptive CLARITY Act, which would merely require VA to publish what it is adding to and taking off these lists, got a hearing on April 29, 2026, and has gone nowhere since.
Both bills exist for the same reason. As the law stands, a Secretary can do this with a signature and no announcement.
The Veteran in the room
One more line on the report card.
Denis McDonough never served. He was the second non-Veteran ever to run the Department of Veterans Affairs. Before VA he was President Obama’s White House Chief of Staff for a full term. Doug Collins has worn the uniform since the late 1980s. Two years as a Navy chaplain, then the Air Force Reserve since 2002, a colonel since 2023, five months at Balad Air Base in 2008 with the 94th Airlift Wing.
It matters, and it does not settle anything. It matters because a Secretary who has been through a deployment understands something about the people in his waiting room that cannot be briefed into him. It does not settle anything because of who signed what. The sentence saying a man’s breast cancer and a woman’s are the same disease was signed by the civilian. The memo deleting it, and the rule saying your rating drops when your medication works, were signed by the colonel. In some ways, that stings worse than had McDonough signed it.
A Veteran at the top is worth having. It is not a substitute for reading your own regulations, and it is not a character reference. Judge the signature, not the service record.
The grade
Denis McDonough gets a C. He was handed a system where 44.5 percent of claims were already late, absorbed the largest expansion of eligibility in a generation, and left with the late share cut to 26.4 percent and the average wait down 47 days. He also presided over a pile that doubled, and over a legal position in Barry that read a regulation, unambiguously, to pay an above-the-knee amputee less than it says. Slow, and wrong in court more than he should have been. But when his Department decided a question about breast cancer, it decided it out of oncology and published its homework. That is worth more than it sounds like.
Really, looking back, McDonough was uneventful.
Douglas A. Collins gets an incomplete, and he has earned both halves of the word. The speed is real, but not in a good way. Two thirds of the backlog gone in 21 months is the best run of numbers VA has produced in a decade. But it was bought with overtime and a shrinking workforce, it turned in June and has been running backwards for 20 weeks, and twice now his Department has gone after the rules themselves rather than the work. A memo in September deleting a cancer presumption on the authority of an executive order about gender, and a rule in February telling Veterans their ratings would fall when their medication worked. He unsigned the second one in 13 days. Albeit, after public outrage. It counts for less than never signing it. The first one he has never taken back at all.
The grading period is not over. The spreadsheet comes out every Monday, and we will be reading it.
Godspeed.
Court will be in recess until the next Secretary.
The files
The complete file
Federal Circuit, No. 2022-1747, decided May 16, 2024. Holds that 38 C.F.R. § 3.350(f)(3) unambiguously permits multiple intermediate-rate SMC increases. Reversed and remanded; costs to Mr. Barry.
Download89 Fed. Reg. 79815 (proposed Oct. 1, 2024), RIN 2900-AR75. Approved and signed by Secretary Denis McDonough on September 19, 2024. Contains VA’s stated medical basis for treating male and female breast cancer alike under 38 U.S.C. § 1120.
DownloadCourt of Appeals for Veterans Claims, No. 23-1798, decided March 12, 2025. Holds that Jones v. Shinseki applies to musculoskeletal ratings where the diagnostic code does not reference medication.
DownloadEvaluative Rating: Impact of Medication, 91 Fed. Reg. 7118 (Feb. 17, 2026), RIN 2900-AS49. The interim final rule rewriting 38 C.F.R. § 4.10, effective on publication, approved by Secretary Collins on February 11, 2026.
Download91 Fed. Reg. 9712 (Feb. 27, 2026). One page, ten days later. “This action does not resolve the legal questions now before the courts.”
DownloadMilVet Law Firm PLLC, Debus, McCauley and Laffoon v. Secretary of Veterans Affairs, Fed. Cir. No. 2026-1469. Petition for review under 38 U.S.C. § 502, dismissed by agreement March 5, 2026, once the rule was withdrawn.
DownloadIngram v. Collins, Fed. Cir. No. 2025-1972, dismissed March 30, 2026, under Rule 42(b). VA abandoned its appeal of the decision it had tried to overrule by regulation.
DownloadEvery figure in this post, in one file: 303 weekly editions of VA’s Monday Morning Workload Report, February 2021 to November 14, 2026, with inventory, backlog, percentage over 125 days and average days pending for each week.
Download